Judas and the Black Messiah Film Review

-

With the nationwide events of the past year, it is quite cathartic to see a film that feels so in tune with current events. Shaka King’s Judas and the Black Messiah is an incredible film with outstanding performances from LaKeith Stanfield, Daniel Kaluuya, and Jesse Plemons.

In case you are unaware, Judas and the Black Messiah follows the true story of William O’Neal (Stanfield) serving as an FBI informant infiltrating the Illinois chapter of the Black Panther Party to investigate Fred Hampton (Kaluuya). As crazy as it may sound, the plot basically functions similar to films like Dances With Wolves and Avatar. The viewer follows O’Neal as he grows closer and closer to the Panthers, sympathizing with them along the way. This could seem redundant, but thanks to Shaka King’s excellent direction, the film comes across as wholly fresh and original.

Direction

That vision from King is one of the film’s strongest bonuses. Despite this only being his sophomore feature, the film is handled with the care and confidence of a true master. Every aspect from the cinematography, to the editing, and to the score, all feel like departures from standard cinematic conventions. The entire film has rogue energy to it. The energy King presents feels wholly his own, creating a unique experience. This reminded me of current directors like Eugene Kotlyarenko and the Safdie Brothers, who operate with their own energetic styles.

Actors

Now I must move on to the biggest attention-grabbers of the film, and that’s the performances. First, to get it out of the way, Kaluuya absolutely kills it as Fred Hampton, chewing up every scene he’s in. Kaluuya truly transformed himself, as all the actors did, into an unrecognizable state. I no longer saw Daniel Kaluuya, but rather the Black Panther leader Fred Hampton. Kaluuya is definitely deserving of award season attention, and I’d even say a win. However, Kaluuya isn’t the only actor acting at the top of his game, because LaKeith Stanfield gives one of the best performances of the year. His acting, while more subdued than Kaluuya’s, is equally as effective and gripping. Stanfield manages to make the audience side with him in every scene with just a simple expression or look. He also makes the audience feel what he feels in every scene, resulting in the film acting as a rollercoaster of emotions. Now on to Jesse Plemons who also gives a phenomenal performance. His character could easily be forgettable and dull, but Plemons adds so much humanization and relatability to the character. Due to incredible performances, I cared for the drama between the actors.

Music

In addition to King’s strong visual eye and the incredible ensemble, the music from the film adds to the experience. The score comes across as multi-genre, and it works because it balances these genre tonal shifts. The score contributes a lot to how the film works as an energetic experience, similar to films like Good Time or Punch-Drunk Love.

Flaws (albeit minor)

My only issues would be some of the conventions the film follows. The film as a whole feels very unique and out there, but the small conventional pieces feel moderately weaker. Just some of the scenes between Hampton and Deborah Johnson are enjoyable but slow down the fast-paced energy.

Overall, Judas and the Black Messiah is a phenomenal film, with outstanding performances and direction. I adored this film and give it a 4.5/5.

The film is free with an HBO Max subscription and I definitely recommend you give it a watch.

Check back to The Roundup for more film reviews!

Blake Woodard '22, Editor-in-Chief
Blake Woodard '22, Editor-in-Chief
In my free time I like to watch movies and play tennis. I play for Jesuit’s tennis team, and like writing for The Roundup.

1 COMMENT

The Jesuit Journal

Fall 2025

The Jesuit Journal provides a space for students interested in writing and visual art with a space to showcase their creative talents.

Latest News

Under the Lights and Onto the Course: Cross Country Season Begins

Under the bright lights, the Jesuit runners lined up on the line knowing months of training had prepared them for this race. Jesuit Cross Country recently held their annual "Thursday Night Lights," a two-mile time trial and yearly tradition...

Solidarity and Faith: Jesuit Dallas Students Embark on Quispicanchi Mission Trip

There, on the imposing shelf of an Andean mountain sat in a staggered circle two groups of high-school age, young adults, drastically different in their upbringing yet remarkably unified. Through grins and laughs, simple translations were exchanged from English...

Bold Predictions for Every NFL Team in 2026 (Vol. 2)

Everybody loves a circular ending. And after three years of writing for the Jesuit Roundup (starting from Freshman year), it's about time I revisit (as a Senior) the article that started everything for my sportswriting. The Bold Predictions For...

Jesuit Rangers Fall to Sachse in Friday Night Setback

The Rangers opened their 2026 season on the road on Friday night, falling to Sachse 52-24 at Homer B. Johnson Stadium. The Rangers moved the ball well at times, finishing with 346 yards of total offense and 23 first...