Confirmation Hearing Day 3 – Judge Amy Coney Barrett

-

On Wednesday, senators began their questioning of Judge Amy Coney Barrett during her third day of Supreme Court confirmation hearing.

Graham praised Barrett for being ‘unashamedly pro-life,’ saying her confirmation will be a breakthrough for conservative women.

“This hearing, to me, is an opportunity to not punch through a glass ceiling, but a reinforced concrete barrier around conservative women,” said Senator Lindsey Graham.
“This hearing, to me, is an opportunity to not punch through a glass ceiling, but a reinforced concrete barrier around conservative women,” said Senator Lindsey Graham.Credit…Erin Schaff/The New York Times
Opening Remarks:

Senator Lindsey Graham, Republican of South Carolina, opened Wednesday’s hearing by proclaiming Judge Amy Coney Barrett’s coming confirmation a historic victory for conservative women who he said have faced steeper obstacles in public life than liberal women.

Mr. Graham said, “This is the first time in American history that we’ve nominated a woman who is unashamedly pro-life and embraces her faith without apology, and she is going to the court.”

Brief Mention of Roe v. Wade:

During the hearings, Judge Barrett has declined repeatedly to answer how she would rule on a challenge to the Roe v. Wade decision that established abortion rights, but she has made clear that she opposes abortion rights.

At the beginning of the second day of questioning by senators, Mr. Graham said, “This hearing, to me, is an opportunity to not punch through a glass ceiling, but a reinforced concrete barrier around conservative women. You’re going to shatter that barrier.”

Furthermore, Mr. Graham echoed statements on Tuesday from the panel’s two Republican women, both of whom argued that conservative women had been marginalized for their beliefs.

Praise:

“I have never been more proud of the nominee than I am of you,” he said. “This is history being made, folks.”

Later, Senator Josh Hawley, Republican of Missouri, echoed Mr. Graham’s praise as he concluded his questions, announcing that he would vote for Judge Barrett and saying: “There’s nothing wrong with confirming to the Supreme Court of the United States a devout, Catholic, pro-life Christian.”

Barrett’s advice for young women: “Make decisions. Be confident. Know what you want. And go get it.”

Question:

Near the end of the third day of hearings on Capitol Hill, Senator Joni Ernst, Republican of Iowa, asked Judge Barrett if she had advice for young women.

Barrett’s Advice:

Judge Barrett said she did, and passed on some guidance that her father had told her.

“One thing I have often told my own daughters is that you should not let life just happen to you or lead you along. You should identify where your objectives are and identify the type of person you want to be and make deliberate decisions to make that happen.”

My dad used to tell us not to make a decision is to make a decision.”

She concluded, “Make decisions. Be confident. Know what you want. And go get it.”

Hopes and Admiration:

Ms. Ernst told Judge Barrett many young women are rooting for her.

“I would share with you that there are thousands upon thousands of young women out there that see the role that you set,” Ms. Ernst said, adding that they see the judge as “someone they can aspire to be.”

Day 3 Full Highlights Vid

Other Important Topics – 
  • Barrett gave a seminar on severability, with an Obamacare subtext.
  • Klobuchar presses Barrett on potential election-related litigation, invoking her role in Bush v. Gore.
  • Barrett refused to discuss climate change, saying it is “a very contentious matter of public debate.”
  • Graham, criticized for invoking ‘good old days of segregation,’ says he was being sarcastic.
  • Peppered with questions on Trump’s powers, Barrett offered no answers.
  • Barrett refused to answer questions on Trump’s family separation policy at the border.

Article Credit: https://www.nytimes.com/live/2020/10/14/us/amy-coney-barrett-live

What to expect at Thursday’s confirmation hearing – 

The Senate Judiciary Committee on Thursday will convene an outside panel of experts to argue for or against Judge Barrett’s confirmation to the Supreme Court, a debate that will take most of the fourth day of high court confirmation hearings.

Breakdown: 

Democrats have called four witnesses to burnish their argument that Judge Barrett’s confirmation to the Supreme Court before Nov. 3 will lead to the Affordable Care Act being overturned, and threaten existing reproductive and civil rights.

Afterward, the confirmation hearing process will conclude. Under the rules, Democrats will insist the committee wait a week to vote on the nomination, postponing the vote to approve her nomination in the committee until Oct. 22.

Final Thoughts: 

In conclusion, Day 3 of the hearing was full of notable events. Ranging from much praise and admiration from young women nationwide to those who pinpointed her evasiveness from questions regarding President Trump’s power and the topic of climate change, Day 3 of the hearing was one to remember.

Time is ticking down until the fourth day of the Judicial Hearing. Furthermore, this will be one of the most important days and most likely serve as the last day of this Judicial hearing.

For more coverage on politics stay tuned to The Roundup for more!

Categories

2 COMMENTS

The Jesuit Journal

Fall 2025

The Jesuit Journal provides a space for students interested in writing and visual art with a space to showcase their creative talents.

Latest News

Lacrosse Makes History with Fifth THSLL State Championship Title

On a sun-soaked Monday afternoon at Lesley Field, the Jesuit Dallas Rangers captured their fifth Texas High School Lacrosse League Class AA State Championship with a 9-8 victory over The Woodlands, capping off one of the most memorable postseason...

Jesuit Crew Finishes Strong Throughout Successful Spring Season Push

The Jesuit Crew Spring Season has been built on the stable belief that the will to win means nothing without the will to prepare. Through countless training sessions and hours of work, the team has proven itself not only...

15 Years Online: The Roundup’s 21st Century Odyssey

For a decade and a half now, The Roundup has brought you only the finest online media. Far have we come from the days of a bi-annual physically printed newspaper! The Jesuit school newspaper is well and truly "with...

Nurse Anna – 2026 Bluebonnet Award Recipient

Occurring in tandem with the national Nurses Day, Jesuit Dallas Nurse Anna Hjertstedt was named one of two Bluebonnet Award recipients across the state of Texas. This prestigious award is given by Cartwheel to recognize often unseen and unrecognized...